Skip to main content

Shedding Light on the Debate on Electric Cars and the Environment

The development of electromobility is essential to reduce transport emissions, as expressed in the Paris Agreement on climate change.

Shedding Light on the Debate on Electric Cars and the Environment

Transportation=pollution. Who hasn't thought of this when looking at the thick layer of pollution that covers our cities' skies, or when we're stuck in traffic with our engines running?

The impact of the transport sector—and especially the automobile sector—on air emissions is an undeniable reality. That is why it is widely regarded that transport policy should prioritize cutting greenhouse gas generation by substituting fossil fuels for cleaner alternatives.

In this sense, transport management can play a key role in promoting the decarbonization of the economy and, ultimately, in combating global warming.

This idea is deeply connected with electro mobility, which refers to the use of vehicles with electric motors. Developing these vehicles is fundamental to reducing transport emissions, as asserted in the Paris Agreement on Climate Change. The advantages of electric cars are evident in terms of air quality, improved population health, efficiency, safety and energy resilience, and reduced dependence on fossil fuels.

Electric vehicles. A solution?

In electric cars, however, not all that glitters is gold. The negative impacts and costs associated with their use are also clear. For example, something that is often overlooked is that producing an electric vehicle causes far more pollution than producing a conventional vehicle. Why is that? The fault lies with the batteries, whose manufacture requires minerals such as lithium, whose extraction emits large quantities of carbon dioxide.

It’s also worth noting that not all electricity is clean. In fact, most electricity produced in the world is generated from fossil fuels, although in this sense Latin America and the Caribbean are far ahead of the curve, because that percentage is less than 50 percent.

This is a debate that is not closed and that at IDB Invest we have very much in mind. What is clear is that, in order to decarbonize our economies, we must not see a single action as a solution, but we must see it, something that the IDB Group has been working for a long time.



Still, we are convinced that electro mobility is a present-day and especially forward-looking option to alleviate the problem of air emissions and combat global warming, providing an opportunity for sustainable development in the region. This is why we include it directly or indirectly in financing agreements, such as the one we signed in 2019 with Cabify, one of the most important ride hailing platforms in Latin America and the Caribbean. Cabify is committed to having its entire fleet of vehicles go electric within five years’ time, and we believe that this is a goal heading in the right direction.

The project, however, goes much further than promoting electrification. For example, we believe that Cabify's expansion can have a very positive impact on areas in the region that are not covered by public transport. The jobs it creates are a flexible alternative to supplement other jobs, which can be particularly beneficial to society during periods of low economic growth. In addition, the agreement encourages the hiring of women drivers, which is in line with our aim to promote gender equality.

Against the backdrop of all these issues, IDB Invest has prepared a report on electric cars in the Mexican ride hailing market, which draws some interesting conclusions about the sector's problems. For example, did you know that a driver in Mexico needs a net monthly income of about 40,000 pesos (more than two thousand dollars) to afford an electric vehicle, but the average income is only 10,000 pesos? Given this economic constraint, it isn’t hard to understand why only 0.01 percent of passenger transport platform vehicles are electric.

In addition to discussing the sector's problems, our report contributes ideas and solutions for electrification.■

Authors

Patricia Yañez-Pagans

Patricia Yañez-Pagans is a Principal Economist in the Development Effectiveness Division of IDB Invest. With extensive experience in impact measurement across multiple areas, both in the public and private sectors, she currently leads the work on ex-post evaluation for the IDB Invest portfolio and the impact knowledge agenda. Patricia joined the IDB Group under the Young Professionals Program and served as an Economist in the IDB's Office of Strategic Planning and Development Effectiveness and as Research Fellow for IDB’s Research Department. She has also worked as a consultant for different institutions, such as the World Bank, UNICEF and the Ministry of Development Planning of Bolivia, and as a Professor of Economics at the Universidad Católica Boliviana. Patricia has a Ph.D. in Applied Economics from the University of Wisconsin-Madison, a Master’s in Applied Economics from Pompeu Fabra University, and a Master’s in Social Policy and Development from The London School of Economics and Political Science.

Financial Institutions

Related Posts

  • A family standing together in a bright, modern living room with simple furnishings and neutral tones, conveying a comfortable residential setting.
    Sustainable Financing for Construction in Mexico: Banco Inmobiliario Mexicano’s Framework

    A sustainable financing framework to strengthen Mexico’s construction sector and help reduce the country’s housing deficit.

  • Business professionals seated around a conference table during a meeting, with one participant reviewing information on a tablet while others applaud, in a modern office setting with glass walls and colleagues working in the background.
    Governance and Succession: Securing the Future of Mexico’s Nonbank Financial Institutions

    IDB Invest study: key findings and a roadmap to strengthen governance and CEO and senior management succession planning in nonbank financial institutions (NBFIs).

  • The image shows a waterfront scene with calm water in the foreground and a row of colorful buildings along the shore in the background.
    Facing the Storm: How IDB Invest Supports Caribbean Private Sector Resilience

    IDB Invest is partnering with the Green Climate Fund to help Caribbean businesses better withstand future climate shocks through blended finance and technical assistance.